ÌìÃÀ´«Ã½

forensic nursing; DNA evidence; molecular evidence; sexual assault; crime-scene trauma; nursing education; forensic readiness; SANE training; ethical challenges; victim advocacy

Introduction

The integral role of nursing professionals in the forensic context, especially concerning the meticulous collection and preservation of molecular evidence, is a subject of increasing focus. This is particularly true for victims of sexual violence and other forms of crime-scene trauma, where the accuracy of evidence can significantly impact legal outcomes. For instance, a study in Ghana brought to light the crucial role of nurses in DNA evidence collection from sexual violence victims, identifying specific gaps in their knowledge and practices. This oversight can compromise the integrity of vital molecular evidence needed for justice, emphasizing the clear need for comprehensive training in forensic principles and DNA collection protocols to ensure reliable evidence for legal proceedings [1].

Building on this, the broader concept of 'forensic readiness' in nursing practice has emerged as essential. An integrative review underscored that nurses must possess the necessary knowledge and skills to effectively identify, collect, and preserve evidence, especially in trauma and crime-related incidents. This readiness ensures the integrity of all evidence, including potential molecular samples, for subsequent legal processes. Consequently, enhancing forensic education for nurses is seen as a vital step towards improving victim outcomes and bolstering the justice system [2].

This specialized training is further detailed in discussions around best practices for Sexual Assault Nurse Examiner (SANE) education. Comprehensive SANE training is critical to equip nurses with the skills for thorough forensic examination and meticulous evidence collection. Such training guarantees that molecular evidence, like DNA, is collected, preserved, and documented with precision, directly influencing the success of legal proceedings for crime-scene trauma victims [3].

While the primary focus often lies on direct evidence collection, genomic and molecular insights also play a foundational role in evidence-based care and forensic understanding. For example, research into microRNAs as potential biomarkers for traumatic brain injury (TBI) can inform nurses about injury severity and prognosis. Though not directly about forensic collection, understanding these molecular markers helps nurses deliver informed care and contributes to a deeper forensic comprehension of injury mechanisms, which can be crucial in crime-scene trauma cases [4].

The multifaceted role of forensic nurses in sexual assault cases extends beyond collection to initial assessment and victim advocacy. Their central position in ensuring the integrity of forensic evidence, including DNA, is vital for legal outcomes, linking nurses directly to the molecular evidence chain and ensuring both proper care and legal accountability [5].

The reach of crime-scene trauma can even touch the nursing profession itself. Investigations into the prevalence of sexual harassment and assault within academic nursing faculty highlight the pervasive nature of such traumas. These situations reinforce the indispensable role forensic nurses play in providing care, support, and meticulous evidence collection, including molecular samples, whenever victims come forward within any setting [6].

Further emphasizing the need for prepared professionals, a study explored the preparedness of nurses in a health district to manage victims of sexual assault. This research underlined the necessity for specialized training to ensure nurses competently provide holistic care, which crucially includes the meticulous collection and preservation of forensic evidence such as DNA. Adequate preparedness directly impacts the integrity of molecular evidence, which is paramount for successful legal outcomes and supporting victim justice [7].

Forensic nursing practice is also fraught with ethical complexities. A systematic review highlighted key ethical challenges, particularly when caring for crime-scene trauma victims. The collection, storage, and use of molecular evidence, like DNA, present implicit ethical considerations, requiring nurses to carefully balance victim advocacy with their legal responsibilities. Understanding these ethical dilemmas is essential for upholding patient rights and maintaining the integrity of forensic processes involving genomic data [8].

Recognizing these needs, national surveys, such as one conducted in Saudi Arabia, point to the critical demand for specialized forensic nursing education and training. This education would develop competencies in handling biological and molecular evidence, ensuring its integrity and utility in legal proceedings, and enabling nurses to effectively contribute to genomic and molecular data collection and interpretation in forensic contexts [9].

Finally, an assessment of emergency department nurses' knowledge and practices regarding forensic evidence collection further reveals areas where education must be strengthened. Ensuring proper handling of all evidence types, including delicate molecular samples, is crucial. Improving nurses' competency in this domain is vital for preserving the integrity of genomic and molecular evidence, ultimately supporting justice and enhancing victim care [10].

Description

Forensic nursing sits at the critical intersection of healthcare and the justice system, demanding a specialized skill set for those caring for crime-scene trauma victims. At its core, this specialty requires nurses to effectively manage and collect forensic evidence, a task often complicated by various factors. Studies show that nurses, particularly in settings such as Ghana, face significant knowledge gaps and practical challenges in collecting DNA evidence from sexual violence victims [1]. This directly impacts the integrity of molecular evidence, which is indispensable for legal proceedings. The absence of comprehensive training in forensic principles and DNA collection protocols frequently compromises the reliability of such evidence, hindering justice for victims [1, 7].

To address these critical shortcomings, the concept of 'forensic readiness' is paramount in nursing practice. This readiness involves equipping nurses with the precise knowledge and skills required to identify, collect, and preserve all forms of evidence, including molecular samples, in incidents related to trauma and crime [2]. Specialized training programs, such as those for Sexual Assault Nurse Examiners (SANEs), are designed to instill these competencies. These programs emphasize meticulous collection, proper preservation, and accurate documentation of molecular evidence, like DNA, which are direct determinants of successful legal outcomes for crime-scene trauma victims [3]. Furthermore, a national survey conducted in Saudi Arabia highlights the widespread need for such specialized forensic nursing education and training to ensure professionals can competently handle biological and molecular evidence, thereby maintaining its utility in legal contexts [9].

The role of forensic nurses extends far beyond just evidence collection; it encompasses a holistic approach to victim care and advocacy. In sexual assault cases, forensic nurses are central figures, from the initial assessment through to evidence collection and ongoing support for victims [5]. Their understanding of the molecular evidence chain is crucial for ensuring proper care and legal accountability. However, challenges persist. For instance, an evaluation of emergency department nurses revealed significant variations in their knowledge and practices concerning forensic evidence collection, particularly for delicate molecular samples. This highlights a pressing need to strengthen education in this area, which would, in turn, preserve genomic and molecular evidence integrity, support justice, and improve victim care [10].

Ethical considerations also form a significant part of forensic nursing practice. Forensic nurses frequently navigate complex ethical dilemmas, especially when dealing with crime-scene trauma victims. The ethical implications surrounding the collection, storage, and utilization of molecular evidence, such as DNA, require a delicate balance between advocating for victim rights and fulfilling legal responsibilities [8]. Understanding these challenges is essential for maintaining the integrity of forensic processes involving genomic data and ensuring patient-centered care within legal frameworks.

While much of forensic nursing focuses on direct victim care and evidence collection, the broader understanding of molecular science also contributes to their practice. For instance, research exploring microRNAs as potential biomarkers for traumatic brain injury (TBI) can inform nurses about injury severity and prognosis [4]. Although not directly about forensic evidence collection, these genomic and molecular insights are fundamental for delivering evidence-based care and enhancing the forensic understanding of injury mechanisms. This contributes to a more comprehensive approach to patient assessment and care strategies in crime-related trauma. Additionally, even discussions surrounding the prevalence of sexual harassment and assault within academic nursing faculty, while not forensic evidence per se, underscore the pervasive nature of trauma and the critical, often unseen, role forensic nurses play in providing care, support, and meticulous evidence collection for victims who choose to come forward [6]. Ultimately, the efficacy of the legal system and the well-being of trauma victims heavily rely on the expertly trained and ethically sound practices of forensic nurses in handling molecular and genomic evidence.

Conclusion

Nurses play a crucial, often underestimated, role in the collection of forensic evidence, particularly DNA, from victims of sexual violence and other crime-scene trauma. Several studies highlight a recurring issue: significant gaps in knowledge and practices among nurses concerning proper techniques for evidence collection, especially in resource-limited settings. This lack of comprehensive training can severely compromise the integrity of molecular evidence, which is essential for successful legal proceedings and achieving justice for victims. The concept of 'forensic readiness' in nursing is vital, encompassing the knowledge and skills needed to identify, collect, and preserve various forms of evidence effectively. The importance of specialized education is a common thread across various contexts. This includes best practices for Sexual Assault Nurse Examiner (SANE) training, which ensures meticulous collection, preservation, and documentation of molecular evidence. Enhancing forensic education for nurses is critical not only for improving victim outcomes but also for strengthening the entire justice system. Nurses need to understand their multifaceted role, from initial assessment to victim advocacy and meticulous evidence handling. Ethical challenges also arise in forensic nursing, particularly concerning the collection and use of molecular evidence, necessitating a balance between victim rights and legal responsibilities. Assessments of emergency department nurses reveal areas where competency in forensic evidence collection needs to be strengthened. Adequate preparedness and comprehensive training, including in forensic principles and DNA collection protocols, are fundamental. Even studies on broader topics like the prevalence of sexual harassment within the nursing profession or microRNAs as biomarkers for traumatic brain injury underscore the extended scope where forensic nursing insights, including those related to genomic and molecular data, become relevant for evidence-based care and understanding injury mechanisms. Ultimately, improving nurses' capabilities in handling molecular evidence is paramount for supporting justice and enhancing victim care globally.

References

1. Edna A, Simon MS, Stella MA (2021) .J Forensic Nurs 17:228-235.

   , ,

2. Marijke Z, Sophie R, Janneke CvB (2022) .J Forensic Nurs 18:219-228.

   , ,

3. Diane AW, Rosemary T, Elizabeth R (2023) .J Forensic Nurs 19:E1-E7.

   , ,

4. Seyed EM, Mostafa K, Ali RM (2024) .Int J Mol Sci 25:2588.

   , ,

5. Majd MA, Reham A, Issam S (2021) .J Clin Nurs 30:21-29.

   , ,

6. Sandra RW, Sherri M, Susan T (2021) .J Nurs Scholarsh 53:194-203.

   , ,

7. Kedibone PM, Carina B, Roshini N (2023) .J Forensic Nurs 19:240-247.

   , ,

8. Regina GK, Sheri MS, Angela MC (2021) .J Forensic Nurs 17:23-32.

   , ,

9. Mohammad AA, Hanan NA, Nidal NA (2023) .J Forensic Nurs 19:103-111.

   , ,

10. Emine A, Serap K, Mustafa Ç (2023) .J Forensic Nurs 19:147-154.

    , ,